Whether you are pregnant, breastfeeding, or a parent of a young child, you're liable to be concerned about the headlines detailing high levels of arsenic in apple juice and rice. Although it may seem like another overblown fear campaign by the media, the truth is frightening and deserves the attention of parents and parents-to-be. The information on the levels of arsenic found in these common foods is not easy to find and has been misreported by several news outlets. Here's what you need to know about this common poison found in food and water.
Arsenic is naturally occurring, but many apple and grape juices, even those labeled "organic" can contain unsafe levels of inorganic arsenic. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has set no safe level for arsenic in juice, but the safe level set for drinking water is no more than 10 ppb (parts per billion) and some organizations advocate lowering that level to 5 ppb or even 3 ppb.
Consuming even low levels of arsenic over time can make people sick in a variety of ways. Low-level exposure has been linked to type 2 diabetes and levels above 5 ppb in drinking water have been linked to lower intelligence. Chronic exposure can cause gastrointestinal illnesses, skin lesions and sufferers may exhibit signs of chronic fatigue syndrome. The World Health Organization estimates that chronic exposure over a period of 5-20 years increases the risk of developing certain types of cancers, high blood pressure, diabetes and reproductive problems.
Consumer Reports recently tested popular apple and grape juices for their arsenic and lead content - the results might surprise you.
100% Apple Juice with High Levels of Inorganic Arsenic
- 365 Everyday Value (100% Organic, Whole Foods) - 7-7.1 ppb
- Apple & Eve - 5-10.5 ppb
- Gerber (4 oz. bottles) - 5.8-9.7 ppb
- Gerber Organic - 5.5-5.7 ppb
- Gold Emblem (CVS) - 3.1-9.4 ppb
- Great Value (Walmart) - 10.1-13.9 ppb
- Minute Maid - 6.2-6.17 pbb
- Mott's - 4-7.9 ppb
- Mott's (4.23 oz juice boxes) - 4-10.2 ppb
- Walgreens - 4-6.8 ppb
100% Grape Juice with High Levels of Inorganic Arsenic
- Golden Emblem (CVS) - 5.9-7.5 ppb
- Walgreens - 9.7-24.7 ppb
- Welch's - 7.1-12.4 ppb
100% Apple and Grape Juices with High Lead Content (over 5 ppb is considered unsafe by the FDA)
- Gerber Apple (4 oz. bottles) - 3.4-13.6 ppb
- Golden Emblem Grape (CVS) - 6.5-8.6 ppb
- Joe's Kids Apple (Trader Joe's, 6.75 oz juice boxes) - 5.3-9.7 ppb
- Walgreens Grape - 10.1-15.9 ppb
- Welch's Grape - 3.5-9.2 ppb
*These results do not include organically-occurring arsenic
The arsenic found in juices is a product of the soil the apples or grapes are grown in and other common sources of arsenic abound in the US, including rice and the most common source: well-water. In fact, rice from the US has some of the highest concentrations of arsenic in the world.
Finding out how much arsenic you're consuming and avoiding it is extremely difficult, but there are some things you can do. To find out how much arsenic is in your body request a urine test at the doctor. If you rely on well-water, contact your local water department to have it tested for arsenic. Avoid rice grown in most US states, China and Chile (however, California has relatively lower levels). Rice grown in Nepal, India, Pakistan and Egypt have some of the lowest levels in the world - an important consideration when feeding your baby his first food, which is typically rice cereal. Lastly, avoid juices that have known high levels of arsenic (see list above). Hopefully, now that this issue has come into the forefront of the media, it will encourage the FDA and health organizations to monitor and test products more efficiently.
What juice does your family drink?
Arsenic in your juice [
ConsumerReports]